>>>>>Like you're doing with this?
Like I am doing with what? You lost me.
>>>>>I'm sorry, what's wrong with "assuming" a theory to be possible... I've experienced gains after applying this... and yes, I was a typical "hardgainer" (compared from what I've noticed reading other's results of Penis Enlargement in general). I was merely trying to write a post that some people might find helpful...wich a few people have already stated that it fit's with what they've experienced and was helpful... and not just in this thread... What about BIB, who claimed to have hung for hour's a day and gained a massive amount of size from it?
What about him? I am trying to understand his relevance to your "heal under strecthed state" argument. Are you suggesting that he was healing while he was hanging?
> I'm sorry it wasn't helpful for you and I'm sorry that it "offended" you.
>>>>"A scientist formulates theories to explain observed events..."
>>>>>Where did you get this?
From the dictionary:
Theory:
1. A set of statements or principles devised to explain a group of facts or phenomena, especially one that has been repeatedly tested or is widely accepted and can be used to make predictions about natural phenomena.
2. The branch of a science or art consisting of its explanatory statements, accepted principles, and methods of analysis, as opposed to practice: a fine musician who had never studied theory.
Also, I happen to be involved in science myself. I'm currently working on my Masters in Human Nutrition. I guarantee you that my definition is compatible with a scientist's definition.
>>>>Do you mean that it hasn't been proven that there are in fact connective tissues in your penis (such as the tunica, ligs, etc.) that limit the expansion and/or length?
No. I don't know where you are getting this from.
>>>>>What about the fact that connective tissue tends to have an elastic/plastic nature?
>>>>What about the fact of genetic differing and the possibility that there may be a higher plastic to elastic ratio and vise-versa in different people?
As I said in my second post....this sounds very interesting, the idea that there might be a difference in plastic/elastic ratio between people. And as I asked before, is there any evidence that such differences exist? I would be interested to know.
>>>>>It may not fit with your definition of "theory",
I use the same definition as every scientist on the planet.
>>>>>But it is a plausible possibility, that might be able to help some people that have tried everything and still have not gained...or gained very little... wich happens quite a bit...and happened with me.
>>>>>>"The "heal under the stretched state" theory implicitly states that it is not possible to gain WITHOUT an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words]. If the tissues are indeed plastic, then they must heal in the state of plastic deformation in order for permanent size changes to occur. Think it through and you will see what I mean. If the current theory as to why an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] works is true, then it should also be impossible to gain without an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words]. Many have gained without an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] (probably more have gained WITHOUT an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] than with an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words]!), therefore the current theory explaining how an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] works does not fit with observed fact. Therefore the current theory is wrong."
>>>>>First, you keep mentioning [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ads[/words]...this "theory" doesn't require the use of an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ads[/words].
OK, but it does require helaing in the stretched state, correct? Now, how is that possible without an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words]?
Piss-pulls throughout that day?
Now how many minutes are devoted towards piss pulls each day? 30 minutes or so? So are you suggesting that all of the healing occurs during those 30 minutes of piss pulls, thus allowing the tissues to heal in the stretched state? What is happening the oyher 23 hours and 30 minutes of day, when you are not wearing an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words], when you are not doing piss pulls? No healing?
>>>>Have you ever heard of [words=https://shop.mattersofsize.com/products/sizegenetics-penis-extender]traction[/words]?
Yes.
>>>>Do you know exactly what these people went through to gain without an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ads[/words]?
No.
>>>>>>... It's wrong of you to assume that there are more people that have gained without an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] than with an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ads[/words]
No it isn't. I base this assertion on the vast majority of posts that I have read on Thunders and [words=http://www.mattersofsize.com/join-now.html]MOS[/words]. Unless these people are lying... or maybe all the [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] people are lurkers..... but there's no reason to assume either of those two things.
>>>>>>> ...all kiddin aside... Does it neccisarily mean that it's the best way?
No, of course not.
Remember, as I stated before, I know there are people who have reported gains from using an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] and/or piss pulls. I'm not denying that they work. What I am trying to do is understand HOW they (and all other Penis Enlargement) work..... so far none of the theories that I have heard so far can explained all the observations.
I am not singling you out......these posts are conveying my general frustration with our lack of understanding of how Penis Enlargement works. I said "our" and I mean all of us... myself included.
>>>>>Like I've already mentioned... this "thoery" might be helpful to other people that have not gained and have tried everything. If you've gained without using this theory...then great. It goes with the fact that everbody is different in one way or another because of differing genetics...wich I've stated from the begining...I've never stated that this "theory" is set in stone for everybody...
>>>>>>"I am NOT saying that an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words] does not work. I am saying that the current theory explaining WHY it works is wrong."
>>>>>>>There are alway's more than one way to skin a cat... why can't there be a few different way's for people to achieve the same end-result, based on different theories?
Look, there's nothing wrong with trying different things in order to find what works. I'm not going to hunt you down, track you down on the street, pull down your pants and rip off your [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words], or follow you into the bathroom and break your fingers for attemptng piss pulls. Do them and good luck with your gains, etc etc.
I'm just trying to understand WHY Penis Enlargement works. So far the explanations I have heard don't make sense. That doesn't mean I FORBID people from trying different things. If anything, I hope that you do try different things and report back to us with your results.
>>>>>>Now, the explanation that "some men have plastic tissues and others have elastic tissues" MIGHT be viable theory to explain why some gain without an [words=http://www.phallosan.com/shop/catalog/default.php?z=eNortjIxtVKyL0pNszWxMFcrSSxKTy2JL0hMT7U1UisoykyxtbBQSy4tLsnPjS8uKcrMS7dVsgZcMMpbEbo%2C]ADS[/words], but I do not know of any scientific evidence to support the claim of a difference of that nature between men in penile tissue composition. It is an interesting suggestion, though.
>>>>>LOL...That's why I called this whole idea...a "Theory"...and not proven fact.
>>>>All I did was try and connect the dots of theory/science into a bigger picture... what's wrong with that?
I didn;t say anything was wrong with that. I am in fact trying to do the same thing.
>>>>"But this theory does not account for girth gains. If it is necessary for men of a "plastic" tissue nature to heal in the stretched state, how do they ever gain any girth? No one walks around all day with a flaccid girth that is bigger than their usual erect girth - not even with a cockring, sorry (I've tried it). "
>>>>>Why are there people who experience girth gains, using only lengthening exercises?
I don;t know. But your response avoid the issue: if the plastic tissue heal under stretched state theory is true, how do you explain those who report girth gains from girth exercises?