5 inch girth is not much in my opinion. Maybe I have a distorted view. I don’t know.
I have 5.7 inches of girth and it feels not big. Maybe because I have big hands, but I would need to have at least 6.5” or 7” in girth to really feel that i’m packing some meat.
And the girls i’ve been with were not impressed with my girth. That was kinda normal/average to them.
It’s not jaw dropping/shocking.
Also my 7 inches length doesn’t look good. I think 8-9 looks more solid. I have a fat pad though.