is there really a difference between jelqing and pumping?

[islandboy22]

ok so this has been wondering in my brain for a while now.
what is the difference between pumping and jelqing?
i mean aren't they basically the same thing?
the idea behind jelqing is to force as much blood into your penis causing it to grow ect.
but doesn't pumping give you the same results? i mean your doing the same exact thing when you pump your just not using your hands.

any input from experienced Penis Enlargement'ers?

sorry if this is dumb to you guys but i honestly dont really see the difference.

 

[Egghead1]

jelqing is a consistant movement of blood. Whereas pumping is more of a stationary thing. I get a lot more fluid build up with pumping but with jelqing its almost impossible for me to get large amounts of fluid build up. IF you only did one OR the other, i think you would gain more from jelqing.

 

[DLD]

Jelqing will produce permanent girth gains while pumping produces non-permanent or minimal girth gains. Many guys like to combine the two for maximum girth expansion.

 

[islandboy22]

yeah but a serious session of pumping brings alot more fresh blood and you get ALOT more swollen after compared to jelqing.
so they thoery behind Penis Enlargement is force your dick into holding much more blood than it is use to holding. then your dick will adapt to it and grow.
and with pumping your dick gets alot more swollen than with manual exersizes.
btw im drunk right now and idk if im even making sense
my bad.

 

[MichaelMyers]

The reason you are so fat after pumpong is because of all the fluid buildup, not more blood being in the penis. I used to pump all the time and yes I would get huge after a session, but it doesn't last. I have gained much more from doing manual exercises and clamping. I will say it is fun to pump up before sex. You get an instant increase of half an inch or more.

 

[Tha3rdLeg]

Here's what I think might be a better question, how is pumping much different from clamping? They both expand the penis and hold the blood stationary in the penis.

I mean there are many people here who say clamping is one of the best girth exercises around and yet act as if pumping isn't almost exactly the same. If clamping creates real girth gains, why wouldn't pumping do the same?

 

[DLD]

I think, if you are able include many different methods into your Penis Enlargement.

 

[MrDirk101]

In my opinion, there is good reason to expect gains from jelqing, but not from pumping.

Jelqing forces an increase in pressure to the internal structures of the penis...the corpus cavernosum and therefore the tunica. Increased pressure, over time, will serve to deform and expand those tissues. That's where girth gains come from.

Pumping, on the other hand, only serves to increase the amount of fluid (blood, plasma, etc) under the skin of the penis. You are not creating "over pressure" in the internal structure. After a brief amount of time, the fluids are re-absorbed into the body and the temporary gains vanish.

Pumping can give you a short term boost, but there is no way (in my view) to create long term real gains that way. The only way to get long term gains is to apply pressure to the right structures over a period of time.