What is the most likely size women class 'huge' as?

I showed my gf the picture of fatcockla that somebody posted on the forum a while back, and she said "you're probably gonna hate me for saying this, but I've had one about that fat before".

Although I didn't say this to her, it was obviously complete bullshit. There are very few people with 8" of natural girth, especially at 16 (how old he was at the time).

She probably assumed it would make me feel jealous or something but I just started this thread so people can discuss (and I'm not being sexist here) how bad female judgement of penis size can be.

So, go on, discuss away..........

I have not seen that guy fatcockla, can you post a link to his pic?

You have good size by the way especially for NBP.

All I know is females are prone to saying some really stoopid shit! But yeah- probably fucking with your head

If a girl could fit that fucking thing up her she would probablly have no problem fitting a shampoo bottle or sumethin up there. I just dont see it happening ?

Maybe it was thick but I find it highly unlikely it was that big. My girth is 6" and most women I was every with thought that was pretty thick. It's my opinion that fatcockla is a pumper who moves the fluid around in his skin. His penis is always kind of different looking in different pictures. Your girl is probably just blowing smoke up your ass. They do that. They like making us jealous.

An ex girl friend told me, that she would have divorced her ex-husband years ago if it was not for the fact that he had a big dick. I figured it was bigger than mine, so I dared not ask how big it was. I relationship went down the hill after that.

Yeh but the point I was trying to make is that, for example, somebody with a 9" penis can fool a reasonably experienced woman in to believing that they are a foot long. This isn't the case with all women and in no way am I making any sexist remarks, but my experience with women has shown that they can NOT estimate the size of a penis.

Oh yeh and about the fat dick guy, seeing as she complains I "leave her walking like a cowboy" with my 5.5 EG I doubt he was anything really over 6". He probably just looked fatter because he was much shorter than I am, creating a fatter illusion.

let's face it guys. of course it is possible she was with a guy that thick. it's no use discussing it here cuz we'll never know the truth. we all know women have problems estimating the size. still it might be true.

women do have a hard time estimating size. they add on another inch or so all the time, very rare are they right on the money.

In my experience, I was only with I chick that was guessed my size right without measuring. Most girls I know are "size queens" and think that around 8" long is average. I'm currently 6" long, and most girls say I'm on the small side.

fallguy said:

An ex girl friend told me, that she would have divorced her ex-husband years ago if it was not for the fact that he had a big dick. I figured it was bigger than mine, so I dared not ask how big it was. I relationship went down the hill after that.

Click to expand...

Heh-heh...you ever think they might have gotten divorced because she was an insensitive bitch?! I'm all for honesty in a relationship, but there is such a thing as tact. Ladies, if your man wants to know, maybe soften the blow if the answer isn't good. For example: "Well, yeah, it was bigger, but baby he didn't know how to use it like you do." or "His was longer but yours is thicker." Jeez, it's no wonder the divorce rate is 50%. It's not about one-upping each other.

Kal-el said:

In my experience, I was only with I chick that was guessed my size right without measuring. Most girls I know are "size queens" and think that around 8" long is average. I'm currently 6" long, and most girls say I'm on the small side.

Click to expand...

Of course women like big dicks, just like we like big tits and ass, but if you're a normal person it's not going to be a deal breaker. However, 6 inches isn't small, it's average. Maybe it's the way YOU are presenting yourself. You know, if you seem ashamed and apologetic of your equipment, the women you're with are going to think so too. Be confident.

Women like the idea of a big dick, but they can't necessarily handle it. It is more the aesthetic pleasure they get from seeing it.

You all make good points. Kong made some good ones especially.

As for the girl insearchof9, she's pulling your chain and you know it.

against_odds21 said:

You all make good points. Kong made some good ones especially.

As for the girl insearchof9, she's pulling your chain and you know it.

Click to expand...

I know, she loves doing it a lot, but she may have genuinely thought it was thicker than it was.


The last female friend I spoke to about penis size said that she thought 8 inches of length was average for a full grown male. She thought that there were 2 penis growth spurts, one was around 14-16 years of age and it grew to an average of 6 inches, then the next one happened at around 17-18 and the penis grew another 2-4 inches then. Shows how much she knows, really.........

I'm 7.25 X 5.5 X 2 inches wide and over the years I've had a reputation among the girls in my town of having a big dick. At least half a dozen have asked to look at it just out of curiosity. I never told them what my exact measurments are, I just let them guess. I look my biggest and measure by biggest when I am about 60% to 75% erect. At this stage it still hangs down but is very pumped and measures NBP at 7.5 inches. 100% erect I measure 7.25 erect but I think that's normal. I would turn my back to the girl, unzip it and wake it up with some dry jelqs and turn around. They were always shocked at my size and usually guess me to be around 9 inches. I would laugh and say it's even bigger hard. At a precise 2 inches wide and 5.5 inches girth the girls have always been very impressed at my thickness as well. I guess I am one of the guy's responsible for the myths of huge cocks that women always claim to have seen. Because I never measure it front of them or let them measure it, my size is speculation. When they tell there friends, they always say that "it was huge, had to at least 9 inches". So yeah, women can be easily mistaken and over estimate penis measurements especially when dealing with someone like myself. I have never lied and said I was larger than I actually am, just in case some sizequeen shows up with a tape measure, I just let them guess.
Remember that "Lie'ers never figure that figures never lie".

sasquatch, that is exactly what I was talking about, nice one!!

insearchof9, you and I are very close to the exact same size, wanna race ??

I'm the smallest guy my GF has been with, but my EX was bragging about my huge 9 1/2 inch dick. Go figure.

sasquatch said:

insearchof9, you and I are very close to the exact same size, wanna race ??

Click to expand...

Hmmm... I think a nice bit of healthy competition does a man good. Whatever happened to the newbie comps? I'll start them up again at the end of this month.